With the printing industry booming, people in all sectors are learning how to get their prints on things. But this is not possible unless they use the right method. Luckily – there are tons to follow.
Using the ideal printing method is not easy, though. That’s why eternal battles like the screen-printing vs heat press surface. People want to know which one is the best – or at least have a better idea of what they get with each one.
Here, we’re going to explain just that. If you’re trying to come up with the perfect printing process or your clothing line or just whatever – then you’ll learn exactly what you need in this article.
So, ready to know the differences between a heat press and screen printing? Then come in!
What is Screen Printing?
First off, let’s explain what screen printing refers to.
This is a fast & easy process that focuses on printing custom images and designs on clothes. The process is not easy, though.
It requires a press, prints, layouts/stencils to follow, and sure enough, the ink. After having all the items, the user needs to print the design using the ink over the layouts, and then let it dry or cure over time. This eventually delivers the screen-print garment.
Despite its complexity, it is seem like a highly cost-effective method.
What is a Heat Press?
Then you will find the heat press method, also called heat transfer. The sole purpose is to transfer a design to clothes and other objects using heat, and a vinyl cutter or inkjet printer to deliver the design with perfect size.
This process takes little to no time, but it requires costly equipment. Yet, it allows users to use a wide array of computer-made design and doesn’t hinder creativity thanks to its simple process.
Even though it feels like a cost-effective choice, a heat press can be a little expensive over time.
Heat Press vs Screen Printing: Factors to Consider
Now that you have a general ideal of what they offer, it is time to learn about the actual difference between screen printing and heat press. For that, we’re going over the most critical factors explained by CraftsInsider blog – such as:
One of the things that differ enormously is the number and type of tools you need to use for each method.
For screen printing, you need a silk screen. This screen is used to create the design for the stencil. The stencil is where the ink will go through, so it goes directly into the garment and/or object.
Of course, there’s no need to use multiple stencils when a single one is enough. But it is probably necessary to use several inks.
As for heat transfer with a heat press, it is necessary to use a heat-printing machine. These come in many different designs and can be costly. However, a standard one can be decently priced and still work well. Apart from that, it is necessary to have a tool to cut the designs, either a vinyl cutter (for vinyl) or an inkjet printer.
So, you can find screen printing affordable yet demands a few more tools. For heat transfer, the tools are more expensive but are fewer.
When we say compatibility, we mean which items and/or types of fabrics you can use with each method. You’ll find that both offer a wide array of uses – yet one is more compatible than the other.
With screen printing, for example, you can use almost any type of natural fabric. This process usually works wonders with cotton, as it goes directly into the material and stays there for long. Silk and wool also work wonders, yet it may be more challenging to print detailed designs on them.
Remember, though, polyester and similar plastic-like materials don’t make it easy for the ink to stick – so avoid them.
For heat press, you’ll find that most fabrics work wonders. You can use heat press on cotton, polyester, cotton/poly blends, lycra, neoprene, and nylon. There’s not much difference in the result, and almost all of them stick well with the heat-pressed design.
So, you’ll find the heat press to be the most compatible of all. But it can be damaging if misused, so be careful.
Speed of Printing
Probably the most significant difference between heat press and screen printing is the speed on which they print.
Screen printing, for example, demands the stencils and ink for every design. If the design is complicated, then several stencils and several inks are necessary. When printing, the process may take a few minutes up to several hours depending on how complex it is – and how much detail is required.
That’s why screen printing is often ideal for simple designs. And the more prints necessary, the better it will feel.
In contrast, heat transfer with a heat press does not demand much apart from the heat press itself and the design. But to obtain the design, it is necessary to have an inkjet printer, vinyl cutter, or similar equipment. Then, the process takes anywhere from a few seconds to a few minutes.
While it allows higher complexity, simple designs are too annoying to do due to the repetitiveness. So it works better when it’s used for small batches of prints but with complex designs.
If one is faster than the other, then it is evident that one is more cost-effective. Well, of course. But it depends.
If you’re printing a T shirt heat press vs screen printing method, you’ll find that the most cost-effective depends heavily on whether you’re printing a few designs or several ones.
Screen printing would be the ideal one for large batches as it uses fewer materials and the process can be automated with the right stencil. Just pick the perfect ink color and that’s it. But if it is a sophisticated design in small batches, having to make several stencils and use different inks may feel inefficient.
You can instead use a heat transfer method that works wonders with intricate designs. Especially when they are just a few, it will create then in less time and with less effort – wasting less material in the process.
But when doing so in larger batches, the heat press becomes more expensive and time-consuming because you can’t automate the process.
So, both have their cost-effectiveness – just in different ways.
Size of Prints
Another critical factor to consider when comparing screen printing vs heat transfer is the size.
For screen printing, the designs are usually small because stencils need to be easy to use by people. That’s why most designs made with screen printing are generally small or don’t take much space in T-shirts and other garments.
A heat press, in contrast, can be enormous. But they’re usually medium-sized, a little larger than a stencil but not that much. Industrial-sized models can cover an entire tablecloth, though.
Here, you’re likely to find heat press capable of delivering larger prints.
Lastly, to know which is better screen printing or heat press – you need to know which one offers the most longevity.
Here, you’ll find that they perform the same way. Despite being completely different processes, the durability tends to be similar.
However, it is more common to find screen-printed designs to crack and wear out than heat-pressed designs. This happens because the ink tends to be more fragile than heat-transferred vinyl.
Screen Printing vs Heat Press: Which One to Choose?
So, which one should you go for? It all depends.
If you need to make large batches of prints with special effects that don’t need much detail and/or complexity – then screen printing is your best bet.
But if you don’t need to print too many designs, these designs are intricate and/or custom, and the materials can go anywhere from cotton to polyester – then go for heat-pressing.
In short, screen printing vs heat press is all about knowing which one works better for your needs. As long as you pick the right one accordingly – then you’ll have no problem enjoying its benefits.